2 year+ check-in: My broken foot is a (mostly) distant memory

I broke my foot back in late 2015 and now 2018 has just begun. So… do I still think about my once-broken foot and does it affect me?

The answer is a little yes, but mostly no.

The truth is, everything has been pretty much fine with my foot once I got rid of the plantars fasciitis that set in after I first started walking again. I blogged about getting it here and fixing it here, but it hasn’t come back since I got that resolved with simple shoe inserts.

That’s not to say, however, I’ve forgotten about my broken foot, even after all this time.

Sometimes when I am walking barefoot, I can feel a tinge of something where my foot is broken — somewhere between discomfort and pain, but very minor. I can easily recreate the pain my shifting my weight to the outside of my foot and onto my fifth metatarsal.

I can reproduce much more pain if push on my baby toe, however. A hard push on my left baby toe does nothing, but the same hard push toward the top of my right foot hurts enough that I need to stop immediately. Still to this day, it just hurts to bend my baby toe.

I suspect I will always have that pain, but I can just live with it. I can’t speak to whether using surgery and screws and all that would’ve prevented it. My break wasn’t perfectly aligned, as you can see in my x-ray photos, but my doctor felt it was quite close and surgery wasn’t necessary.

One of the most noticeable things as I was trying to get back to normal, as I mentioned previously, was the balance in my right foot was terrible after I got back to walking normally. I could stand on my left foot and, ya know, just stand there. But on my right foot, I would wobble and the muscles in my foot would jerk all around trying to keep me in place. I eventually would fall out of place, whereas on my left foot I could stand there forever. It was pretty crazy how obvious and different it was.

I went to a doctor for a check-up on my foot, who gave me exercises to strengthen my foot and improve my balance. But much like when I took piano lessons or was in school, I didn’t do my homework. Instead, eventually over time this has just seemed to resolve itself. I do think I still balance better on my left side if I stand on one foot, but I can stand on my right foot now.

Sometimes I get people visiting this blog who are in the thick of their broken foot and they are typically, well, quite miserable and quite frustrated. I sympathize. It was a depressing for few weeks after my foot broke. But I can say, once you get past it, you pick up where you left off, get back to normal and you start to forget how much it sucked.

So, that’s it. After you break your foot, you might get plantars fasciitis. Your balance will probably be bad in your formerly broken foot. And you may always have a little bit of pain at the break site. But life moves on.

Here’s to 2018 and no broken bones.

 

20 thoughts on “2 year+ check-in: My broken foot is a (mostly) distant memory

  1. Terri Patrick

    Did you break heal? I broke my 5th metatarsal on my right foot 11/7/17, and there has not been much closure on the gap. My break was in alignment and they said no surgery, but since there has been very little healing, they now are talking a bone stimulator and if that doesn’t do the trick, surgery. I was wondering how long it took.

    Like

    1. It did heal. You can see on my blog that after about 9 weeks the x-ray showed some cloudiness, like the break was filling in with bone. I never got another x-ray after that, but I assume it’s totally filled in now. Have you tried walking or putting weight on it?

      1) My doctor said I needed to put some weight on it after 6 weeks. I read that using your foot and putting weight on it can force the bone to grow and support you. My doctor left me with the impression that not putting weight on it wasn’t helping and might be holding me back from progress.

      2) My x-ray after 6 weeks looked the same as it did from the beginning, but my doctor wiggled my toe around and saw it was moving as a unit, so soft tissue was holding it together and filling in the break site. So he said since it was binding together, I should start walking because it was close to healed, even if the x-ray wasn’t showing it.

      My doctor warned me of a non-union being possible, but he said it was rare. If you have a “Jones fracture” it might be more common. But that’s not what I had. Good luck!

      Like

    2. Terri Patrick

      Well, here we are week 22. Break is still present, but after using the oh so expensive bone stimulator for 44 days, it is starting to close. Go back to dr. on April 30. On second boot as the first one’s top strap broke.

      Like

      1. Have you been putting weight on your foot? My doctor felt that would spur along the bone growth. As I mentioned somewhere on this blog, at one point, my x-ray still showed the break quite clearly, but when my doctor moved my toe, the bone moved as a unit and didn’t hurt. So it started healing and filling in before the x-ray showed it. So I started walking and basically started getting back to normal, even though my x-ray didn’t indicate it had healed. Good luck.

        Like

      2. Terri Patrick

        No weight bearing per doctors orders. I do walk on the heal of my boot though. Go back on the 30th of this month. Keep your fingers crossed for good results.

        Like

  2. I just read your entire foot saga. It was very comforting and informative, since I broke my fifth metatarsal on April 1, 2018. My break is on my left foot, but looks very similar to yours. So, my healing has just begun! I’ll be referring back to your timeline. Thanks for putting it all down.

    Like

    1. Good luck! It feels like it’s taking forever and it’s a bummer, but you’ll be back on your feet in no time so just keep in mind it’s temporary! I was depressed for a couple weeks in the thick of it, but it’s a distant memory now. 🙂

      Like

      1. wigingtongirl

        I’m sharing my progress because this blog and all the responses have been so helpful. Last week after half cast, cast, then boot for 11 weeks, I was finally allowed weight bearing and an orthotic shoe. The break is healing in some areas, but not all and surgery was mentioned again, as well as bone stimulation. However, I’m feeling very optimistic because ever since I got into the shoe, I can do so much more. That being said, being inactive for so many weeks, as well as the unbalanced stress on my back , hips and knees, has taken a toll. I have asked for some physical therapy to assist with strengthening those areas as well as my foot. A broken fifth metatarsal is no joke. This has been a long recovery (broke it April 1st), but recover it is! Good luck to all those others that are reading this and going through the same. Once again, thanks for your blog!

        Like

  3. Karen Alexander

    I also enjoyed reading your blog in the depths of my despair after breaking the fifth metatarsal on my left foot on Feb 24th. I’m now nearing the end of week 10 and can now weight bear and will get rid of the boot in 2 weeks. I am attending my nieces wedding and have been able to walk with the help of a walker or cane and I can now see the finish line. It’s been the most depressing time of my life but the time does eventually pass and the end is in sight. Thanks for sharing and caring. I can’t wait for this to be over

    Like

      1. Karen Alexander

        Yes me too. I attended the wedding in Philadelphia and even had to climb stairs. I live in Florida in a ranch home so I had avoided that. I came back much stronger and now only use a cane and started driving again.

        12 days to go. Can’t wait!!

        Like

  4. Karen Alexander

    Feeling almost normal after 16 weeks. If I do too much my foot hurts but somehow I endured and am back to enjoying life

    Like

  5. Sara

    Hey all! your comments have been helpful… my break looks the same as yours..I’ve had it measured in A and E now.. is apparently 3.7mm apart.. I broke the 5th metatarsal on 3rd May and was assured that even though it was a bit displaced it should heal. I went to my GP in the mean time and he assured me the same and around week 7 said I should try and weight bear a little on it to help it healing. the consultant had also said can weight bear a tiny bit.. so i was careful bjt followed orders. Any way I went to A and E on Wednesday because I tripped and put the boot foot (had a cast for 6 weeks and now a boot) out to save myself stupidly.. I was told I had don’t no further damage but there had been no further healing! I’m on about the 10 week Mark now so was and am absolutely gutted and am now thinking i should.push for surgery. I’m at Uni and work so it’s really impacting now! Also how much resting is everyone doing? I am out and about a lot still.but constantly sitting. just get very bored staying inside. am seeing the consultant tomorrow and am so apprehensive. feel like I have wasted the last 2 month’s completely ! :/

    Like

    1. The healing on the x-ray kind of shows up at once. I finished my treatment without ever seeing the bone filled in on the x-ray. The important thing is your toe moving as a unit – at least that’s what my doctor told me. He wiggled my baby toe and I didn’t feel any pain and he said that’s good – it means soft tissue has filled in and the bone was moving as a unit. That meant I could walk. The x-ray still showed a clean break and didn’t show any signs of healing. (This happened at my doctor’s visit at the six-week point, which I blogged about but I’m not sure I mentioned the toe wiggling, which stands out in my mind now three years later.) Good luck!

      Like

  6. MISS SARA MAYER

    Aww thank you thats reasurring about the x ray. I had my appointment again on the 9th with the consultant and he reassured me its healing but i could see not a lot of change again. My little toe has been able to wiggle the whole time which is wierd lol!

    I went to the GP too just to make sure as I was getting paranoid i was being “fobbed off” and he agreed with the consultant but also said I should be trying to put MORE weight on it to promote bone healing. The consultant didn’t mention that though :/ Also when I have put a bit of weight on my heel it REALLY hurts. Not the break but just the heal! Did mention taht to the GP but he didnt seem fussed.

    Wigtongirl was your break displaced? Sorry if you have already said. Mine is apparently 3.7mm apart and thats why its taking longer?! Im still in a boot and 2 crutches at week 10 and had cast for 6 weeks.

    Like

    1. Marian

      Hi there, I’m so thankful for this blog. I’m so frustrated right now after 9 weeks of breaking my fifth metatarsal. For the first 6weeks I was treated by an orthopedic doctor that doesn’t specialize in feet (why? I still ask myself that question) the scheduling department wrongfully scheduled me with him, he didn’t say anything until 6 weeks later when we started questioning why it wasn’t healing and we brought up the question about surgery, he said he doesn’t feel comfortable with feet and referred me to a foot orthopedic surgeon. I was furious. The foot doctor said it is now too late for surgery because some bone has started to form and he would have to basically break it again to realign the bone. But then he said it will heal but probably leave a small gap. I had another orthopedic doctor that looked at my case and said I should’ve had surgery at the beginning but now it would complicate things and it would be like starting all over again: incision, splint, boot, crutches, fruatration. I feel desperate and wish I knew if it ever going to heal all the way since it’s such a big gap. I’m going next week for a third opinion to decide what to do surgery or no surgery? Anyone out there any ideas?

      Like

      1. Hey Marian, what happened with your break? I’m not doctor but my guess would be that the break would fill in with new bone, it would just take a little longer if the gap was bigger. How’d it go?

        Like

Leave a comment